| Place | Bib | Name | Time | State | Country | Citizenship |
| 1 | 8 | Meb Keflezighi | 02:09:15 | CA | USA | USA |
| 2 | 6 | Robert Kipkoech Cheruiyot | 02:09:56 | | Kenya | KEN |
| 3 | 4 | Jaouad Gharib | 02:10:25 | | Morocco | MAR |
| 4 | 5 | Ryan Hall | 02:10:36 | CA | USA | USA |
| 5 | 11 | Abderrahime Bouramdane | 02:12:14 | | Morocco | MAR |
| 6 | 9 | Hendrick Ramaala | 02:12:30 | | South Africa | RSA |
| 7 | 15 | Jorge Torres | 02:13:00 | CO | USA | USA |
| 8 | 19 | Nick Arciniaga | 02:13:46 | MI | USA | USA |
| 9 | 10 | Abdi Abdirahman | 02:14:00 | AZ | USA | USA |
| 10 | 16 | Jason Lehmkuhle | 02:14:39 | MN | USA | USA |
| 11 | 12 | Jackson Kotut Kipkoech | 02:15:10 | | Kenya | KEN |
| 12 | 21 | Peter Gilmore | 02:15:22 | CA | USA | USA |
| 13 | 39 | Migidio Bourifa | 02:16:01 | | Italy | ITA |
| 14 | 29 | Mike Sayenko | 02:16:38 | WA | USA | USA |
| 15 | 28 | Mike Reneau | 02:16:45 | WI | USA | USA |
| 16 | 45 | Jose Telles De Souza | 02:17:28 | | Brazil | BRA |
| 17 | 34 | Allen Wagner | 02:17:49 | PA | USA | USA |
| 18 | 24 | Max King | 02:19:11 | OR | USA | USA |
| 19 | 40 | Mohammed Awol | 02:19:31 | NY | USA | ETH |
| 20 | 18 | Christopher Raabe | 02:19:49 | DC | USA | USA |
| 21 | 23 | Pat Tarpy | 02:20:43 | RI | USA | USA |
| 22 | 2292 | Antonio Liuzzo | 02:22:36 | NY | USA | ITA |
| 23 | 49 | Helder Ornelas | 02:22:44 | | Portugal | POR |
| 24 | 205 | Brett Winegar | 02:23:11 | WA | USA | USA |
| 25 | 47 | Bryan Morseman | 02:23:50 | NY | USA | USA |
| 26 | 8963 | Filippo Lo Piccolo | 02:24:04 | NY | USA | ITA |
| 27 | 33 | Josh Eberly | 02:24:10 | CO | USA | USA |
| 28 | 1076 | Nelson Laux | 02:24:19 | CO | USA | USA |
| 29 | 42 | Kassahun Kabiso | 02:24:43 | NY | USA | ETH |
| 30 | 214 | Andrew Cloke | 02:24:48 | DE | USA | USA |
| 31 | 14 | Brian Sell | 02:24:59 | MI | USA | USA |
| 32 | 52 | Dan Mcgrath | 02:25:05 | NY | USA | USA |
| 33 | 226 | Felipe Garcia | 02:25:24 | NY | USA | MEX |
| 34 | 79 | Hermann Achmuller | 02:26:14 | | Italy | ITA |
| 35 | 203 | Antonio Santi | 02:26:23 | | Italy | ITA |
| 36 | 229 | Stuart Burton | 02:26:24 | OR | USA | GBR |
| 37 | 220 | Tito Fiorenzo Tiberti | 02:26:34 | | Italy | ITA |
| 38 | 43 | Halefom Abebe Tsegaye | 02:26:35 | NY | USA | ETH |
| 39 | 58 | Francisco Ribera | 02:26:48 | | Spain | ESP |
| 40 | 204 | Victor Rodrigues | 02:26:56 | | France | FRA |
| 41 | 59 | Oleksander Holovnytskyy | 02:27:39 | NY | USA | UKR |
| 42 | 46 | Deresse Deniboba | 02:27:48 | NY | USA | ETH |
| 43 | 221 | Mirko Canaglia | 02:27:52 | | Italy | ITA |
| 44 | 207 | Miguel Beltran Mendez | 02:27:59 | | Spain | ESP |
| 45 | 48 | Benjamin Paredes | 02:28:01 | | Mexico | MEX |
| 46 | 245 | Larry Contrella | 02:28:11 | NY | USA | USA |
| 47 | 8962 | Francesco Duca | 02:28:15 | NY | USA | ITA |
| 48 | 41 | Sergey Kaledin | 02:28:17 | | Russia | RUS |
| 49 | 1080 | Stephen Littler | 02:28:42 | | Great Britain | GBR |
| 50 | 222 | Michael Cassidy | 02:28:57 | NY | USA | USA |
| 51 | 57 | Giovanni Ruggiero | 02:29:02 | | Italy | ITA |
| 52 | 1088 | Martin Matthews | 02:29:30 | | Great Britain | GBR |
| 53 | 38 | Tesfaye Girma | 02:29:36 | NY | USA | ETH |
| 54 | 1141 | Francisco Javier Rodriguez Tovar | 02:29:41 | | Spain | ESP |
| 55 | 233 | Brian Wilder | 02:29:53 | | Great Britain | GBR |
| 56 | 55 | C Fred Joslyn | 02:29:54 | NY | USA | USA |
| 57 | 2029 | Didier Brocard | 02:30:14 | | Switzerland | SUI |
| 58 | 20 | Fasil Bizuneh | 02:30:28 | AZ | USA | USA |
| 59 | 1002 | Andrew Allstadt | 02:30:33 | NY | USA | USA |
| 60 | 2083 | Veloso Francisco | 02:30:46 | | Belgium | BEL |
| 61 | 2061 | Alessandro Dilello | 02:31:06 | | Italy | ITA |
| 62 | 234 | Michael Dixon | 02:31:22 | NJ | USA | USA |
| 63 | 1061 | Brian Arreborg Hansen | 02:31:26 | | Denmark | DEN |
| 64 | 243 | Daniel Whitt | 02:31:37 | NY | USA | USA |
| 65 | 689 | Michael Harbus | 02:31:41 | NY | USA | USA |
| 66 | 2195 | Joe Mundt | 02:31:41 | KS | USA | USA |
| 67 | 225 | Enrico Vivian | 02:31:57 | | Italy | ITA |
| 68 | 754 | Steven Kinney | 02:31:58 | NY | USA | USA |
| 69 | 236 | Christoph Hubacher | 02:32:03 | | Switzerland | SUI |
| 70 | 1170 | Peter Vail | 02:32:05 | CO | USA | CAN |
| 71 | 778 | Rob Hampson | 02:32:10 | NY | USA | USA |
| 72 | 211 | Adam Nevens | 02:32:14 | CA | USA | USA |
| 73 | 1152 | Pierre Senac | 02:32:32 | | France | FRA |
| 74 | 2280 | Ryan Linden | 02:32:40 | MI | USA | USA |
| 75 | 2296 | Noreddine Khezzane | 02:32:41 | | France | FRA |
| 76 | 30 | Chris Lundstrom | 02:32:45 | MN | USA | USA |
| 77 | 1071 | Primoz Kobe | 02:33:02 | | Slovenia | SLO |
| 78 | 240 | Tom Dichiara | 02:33:13 | NY | USA | USA |
| 79 | 54 | Gabriele Abate | 02:33:20 | | Italy | ITA |
| 80 | 246 | Ulrich Fluhme | 02:33:31 | NY | USA | GER |
| 81 | 215 | Miguel Angel Pulido Garcia | 02:33:33 | | Spain | ESP |
| 82 | 2131 | Aaron Hoover | 02:33:43 | CO | USA | USA |
| 83 | 208 | Ramon Maria Perea Hormigo | 02:33:46 | | Spain | ESP |
| 84 | 657 | Jeremy Battles | 02:33:54 | NY | USA | USA |
| 85 | 759 | Orest Babyak | 02:34:21 | NY | USA | UKR |
| 86 | 1142 | Francisco Roman Fernandez | 02:34:31 | | Spain | ESP |
| 87 | 7114 | Karl Byrne | 02:34:43 | FL | USA | IRL |
| 88 | 750 | Andreas Groth | 02:34:46 | | Denmark | DEN |
| 89 | 2082 | Keith Forlenza | 02:34:49 | NY | USA | USA |
| 90 | 216 | Adam Siepiola | 02:34:52 | NY | USA | USA |
| 91 | 2158 | Eric Larripa | 02:35:02 | | France | FRA |
| 92 | 223 | Jerry Faulkner | 02:35:09 | OK | USA | USA |
| 93 | 1081 | Frank Loeschner | 02:35:20 | | Germany | GER |
| 94 | 202 | Justin Nyberg | 02:35:28 | NM | USA | USA |
| 95 | 877 | Michael Arnstein | 02:35:34 | NY | USA | USA |
| 96 | 512 | Adam Mulia | 02:35:40 | NY | USA | USA |
| 97 | 232 | Paolo Bravi | 02:35:47 | | Italy | ITA |
| 98 | 1001 | G. Casanova Alig | 02:36:05 | NJ | USA | USA |
| 99 | 1156 | Alemayehu Sitotaw | 02:36:14 | | Norway | NOR |
| 100 | 1044 | Pedro Espinosa | 02:36:16 | NJ | USA | |